Performance Management for Small Businesses: A UK Guide

HR & Employment

Performance Management for Small Businesses: A UK Guide

One underperforming person is noticed by the whole team, and the owner is usually the one who has to deal with it. Here’s how to set expectations, keep on top of performance day to day, and handle underperformance fairly when it happens.

Last updated: November 2026  ·  9 minute read

Once a year The minimum Acas suggests for reviewing an employee’s performance
6 months The unfair dismissal qualifying period from 1 January 2027, down from two years (due)
Day one When a discrimination claim can be brought, whatever the length of service

In a small team, one person who isn’t pulling their weight is noticed by everyone, and it’s usually the owner who has to deal with it. Many owners put it off. The conversation feels awkward, there’s no process to follow, and it’s easier to hope things improve. They rarely do, and by the time action is taken the problem is bigger and the paper trail is missing. This guide covers how to set expectations, keep on top of performance day to day, and handle underperformance fairly when it happens.


What performance management involves

Performance management is the everyday work of making sure people know what’s expected of them, getting regular feedback on how they’re doing, and getting help if they fall short. It isn’t the same as discipline, and it doesn’t have to be formal. In a team of five, much of it is a ten-minute conversation on a Friday afternoon.

Done well, it stops most problems before they start. A person who knows what good looks like, and hears early when they’ve missed it, usually has a chance to put it right. The formal steps in this guide are for the minority of cases where that doesn’t work.


Setting objectives that work

Vague expectations are the root of many performance problems. If you’ve never said what you want, it’s hard to complain when it doesn’t happen.

Acas suggests setting objectives that are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound. They should reflect the person’s normal work and workload, though they can stretch them to develop new skills. Our guide to setting business goals covers the same approach at company level.

💡
An example from Acas An employee agrees to cut their average customer email response time by 48 hours. They do it with automatic acknowledgements and reply templates, and review progress after three months. The target is clear, the method is practical and there’s a date to look at it again.

Write the objectives down and give the employee a copy. Three or four clear ones are better than a long list nobody remembers.


Check-ins and reviews

Two habits cover most of what you need.

1
Regular one-to-ones

A short, regular conversation about how things are going, what’s getting in the way and what’s coming up. Fortnightly or monthly works for most small teams. Give feedback as you go, not just at review time.

2
A proper review, at least once a year

Look at what’s gone well, what hasn’t, what support or training the person needs and where they want to go next. It’s also a chance for them to raise problems of their own. Keep a written record and share it with them afterwards.

Casual and agency workers don’t have to be reviewed, but a short chat now and then does no harm.


Capability or conduct?

Before you act, work out what sort of problem you have, because the right response depends on it.

Type of problem What it looks like Usual response
Capability The person can’t do the job to the required standard, perhaps through lack of skills, training or support Coaching, training, clear targets and time to improve
Conduct The person could do the job but isn’t following the rules, such as lateness, unauthorised absence or poor behaviour An informal talk first, then the disciplinary route. See our disciplinary guide

The two overlap. Someone who is regularly late might be struggling with a health condition, or a long commute that changed when you moved premises. Ask before you assume. If the cause turns out to be a disability, you’ll need to consider reasonable adjustments first (see section 8).


Start with a conversation

Whatever the cause, talk to the person first. Choose a private moment, describe what you’ve seen with a few concrete examples, and ask for their side. Often there’s an explanation you didn’t know about, such as a change at home, unclear instructions or a piece of equipment that keeps failing.

Agree what needs to change, what help you’ll provide and when you’ll check again. Then follow up, and write a short note of what was said. Many problems end here.


A performance improvement plan

If the informal route hasn’t worked, a performance improvement plan, or PIP, puts the next steps in writing. It should set out:

  • The specific problem, with examples, so there’s no doubt about what’s wrong.
  • Specific objectives that are measurable, so both of you can tell whether they’ve been met.
  • A reasonable timeline, with dates for review meetings. Acas doesn’t give a set period. Give long enough for the person to show improvement, bearing in mind the nature of the job.
  • The support you’ll provide, such as training, coaching, a mentor or better equipment.
  • What happens next if the objectives aren’t met.

Talk the plan through with the employee, give them a written copy, and hold the review meetings you’ve promised. Employers sometimes write a PIP and then leave it, and that undermines the whole thing. Offering adequate support is part of being fair, so make sure the person has what they need to do the job.


When the plan doesn’t work

At the end of the plan, look at the evidence and decide where things stand.

  • Some progress, but not enough. You can extend the plan with new dates and, if needed, more support.
  • No real improvement. Move to the formal stage. That usually means a final written warning, and then dismissal if the problem carries on.

The formal stage follows the same steps as a disciplinary: a written invitation, a meeting, the right to be accompanied, a written decision and an appeal. Our guide to handling a disciplinary walks through each one. Dismissal for poor performance should be a last resort and must be fair, with a genuine opportunity to improve beforehand.


Health and disability

⚠️
Think about disability before you go formal If poor performance is linked to a disability, you have a legal duty to consider reasonable adjustments, such as extra time for written tasks, adjusted shifts or specialist equipment. Dismissing someone, or giving a warning, because of something arising from their disability can be discrimination. These claims don’t need any minimum length of service.

In practice:

  • Talk to the employee about what’s affecting their work and what might help. Never assume someone can’t do their job.
  • Record what you discussed and agree it with them.
  • Review whether any adjustments have helped, and note what else you considered and why you didn’t use it.
  • Consider occupational health advice where it would help you understand the situation.

Where long-term illness is the problem, dismissal should be a last resort. Take advice before going down that road. Our statutory sick pay guide covers the pay side of sickness absence.


Keeping records

If a performance case reaches a tribunal, the first question is what you did and when. Keep:

  • Objectives and review records
  • Notes of one-to-ones where performance was discussed
  • The informal conversation, with the date and what was agreed
  • Any improvement plan, and notes of each review meeting
  • Evidence of the support and training provided
  • Warning letters, meeting notes and the outcome of any appeal

Share notes with the employee so they can correct anything they disagree with. It helps to keep a record that they’ve seen it.


Changes to the rules

Two changes make good performance management more important.

  • Unfair dismissal. The qualifying period is due to drop from two years to six months for dismissals on or after 1 January 2027, and the cap on compensation is due to be removed. Until now, an employer could dismiss someone in their first two years without facing an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. After the change, anyone with six months’ service will be able to bring one, so probation reviews need doing properly, and capability concerns about a new starter need a documented process from the start.
  • Tribunal time limits. From 1 October 2026 the time limit for bringing most employment tribunal claims rose from three months to six.

The dates for future changes have moved before, so check GOV.UK or Acas. Acas has also been consulting on a revised Code of Practice for disciplinary and grievance procedures, which would encourage early, informal resolution of problems.


Common mistakes

1
Never saying what’s expected

Then being unhappy when it doesn’t happen.

2
Saving feedback for the annual review

The person hears about problems months too late.

3
Skipping the informal stage

Going straight to warnings usually backfires.

4
Assuming it’s a conduct problem

It may really be capability, training or health.

5
Writing a plan and then forgetting it

No review meetings and no support undermines the whole thing.

6
Setting a target nobody could meet

Or one that changes halfway through.

7
Not keeping records

There’s nothing to show how the problem was handled.

8
Ignoring a possible disability

Until the process is already underway.


Useful resources

More guides for UK small business owners

Right Hand Man covers everything from business finance and bookkeeping to hiring your first employee and choosing an accountant. Browse our guides or get in touch if you have a question.